Cat imageSailing barge image

Mike Stevens' UK Inland Waterways Pages

Narrowboat image

HUMOUR

THE GREATEST WATERWAY NEVER BUILT

by Mike Stevens

It is well-known that many river-names are derived from explorers' and invaders' misunderstandings of the native tongue, such as the Roman misunderstanding that the Celtic word avon (meaning river) was the proper name of this particular river. And that one. And another. And then there's one over here ….

A more modern example dates from 1883, when a number of Indian Civil Servants were seconded to the Colonial Office in London to work on plans for the South East Asia Navigation. One of these, Billda Vies, saw an un-named tributary of the Mekong which he felt might be suitable for canalisation as part of the route. Billda asked his colleague, Sir Syd Enham-Hill (a native of the Sarflund'nah tribe) "I say, old chap, you couldn't be telling me the name of this jolly old river here, could you, what, what?". The beknighted native replied in his own Sarflunnun tongue with an expression of ignorance, which the Indian, no expert in this particular tribal language, took to be the name of the river, which he then transcribed onto the official map, River Gawdnoze.

The South East Asia Navigation had a very interesting history, and almost certainly qualifies for the title of "the greatest waterway never built". Originally proposed by speculators in 1820 as an ambitious scheme for a grand cross of canals, linking the waters of the Indus with those of the Ganges, with linked waterways northwards to Nepal and south to Madras, it was named the Ganges-Indus & North-South Line Indian Navigation Gamble or GIN-SLING. Some initial survey work was done by a team led by Sir Christie Nawood-Inge who reported that because of the need for the 57-mile Harekrishna tunnel through the Karakoram region on the line to Nepal, it would be necessary to build the whole system to a narrow beam, so the standard Brindley gauge of 72' x 7' was adopted.

The project ran into political problems when the India Office (as it then was) began surveys on the ground. The plan had acquired the name Grand Cross in memory of the earlier work by Brindley, and this provoked considerable opposition in the Moslem areas of the Raj. So the scheme was cut back to what was known as the Grand Crescent, a much less ambitious project, whose proper name was the Madras-Calcutta Canal (or MCC). This proved to be of too limited scope to attract investors, so the plan was dropped.

It was revived after the Franco-Prussian War as an even more ambitious Anglo-French project, with additional lines to connect the Raj to Singapore and to link with the French Colonies in South East Asia, thus helping to cement Anglo-French diplomatic and trade links. Such an ambitious proposal took many years in the planning stage. Now named the South East Asia Navigation, the work was under the direction of the British Brig.Gen. Maurice "Mo" Leigh-Mockford and the French M Martin Fulbourne-Evry-Minette. It was for this planning that Billda Vies and his colleagues came to London.

Apart from the Harekrishna tunnel, the major engineering work was to be in the Gawdnoze Gorge, on the North-East India - Laos Link section of the navigation (known as the SEAN NEILL). Here the river drops a distance of 500 ft in the remarkably short distance of only 750 feet (the Viagra Falls). The gorge was too narrow for the navigation channel to take a longer winding route with a lot of locks, so the first proposal was for a staircase of 10 locks, each 50 ft deep ("Neptune's Loft-Ladder"). However concerns that the available water supplies would not be adequate for such deep locks led to a postponement of the plans.

In was in the 1920s that the Indian engineer, Professor C Hrisdeu Char, came up with a workable solution. He realised that in a staircase of locks, the amount of water used in a through passage depends only on the size of the individual lock, not on the number of them, so a larger number of shallower locks would be more water-efficient, so he proposed instead a staircase of 100 locks, each 5ft deep.. But how to fit them into the confines of the Gawdnoze gorge? This was where Prof. Char had his great inspiration : instead of building the locks 72ft long by 7ft-and-a-bit wide, he planned them 72ft wide and 7'6" long to take the boats through sideways. Clearly mitre gates on locks of such dimensions were not feasible, so the flight was designed with guillotine gates, except at the top and bottom, where the boats entered or left the locks conventionally, thus producing top and bottom locks whose gates were on adjacent rather than opposite sides. The drawings of this staircase were truly dramatic, with its 99 guillotine gates, each 72' wide and a considerable height (as is necessary for a staircase), stacked up the side of the gorge, each only 7'6" from its neighbour. It would have been a unique piece of engineering, and was dubbed by its designers "Neptune's Toast-rack".

Sadly by the time the plans were ready to go out to tender, Singapore had fallen to the Japanese, and the project was never completed. I feel the story is worth re-telling. Only the names have been changed to offend the innocent.

Link to history maps (not suitable for text-only browsers)

Page-top link
Go to the top of this page.
Link to index of humorous writing
Go to index of humorous writing
---

UK Canals web ring pic The UKCanals WebRing

This site owned by
Mike Stevens
Previous Site List Sites Random Site Join Ring Next Site
SiteRing by Bravenet.com
Link to home page
Home
Link to London Waterways index
London
Link to history maps (not suitable for text-only browsers)
History
Link to trip reports index
Cruises
Link to quizzes index
Quizzes
Link to cartoons & humour index
Humour
Link to reviews index
Reviews
Link to 'About Me' index
About me
Link to links page
Links.

This page was up-loaded on 30 September 2000 and last up-dated (layout only) on 2 February 2002,

E-mail me
E-mail me.

Originally written as a posting to the newsgroup uk.rec.
waterways and a couple of mailing lists.
Many of the names in the article are puns on the names of people well-known in the groups.
Copyright, © Michael L Stevens, February 2000.